出版与作家生涯2013pleasedontbuymybookonamazon.com
拜托，别在亚马逊上买我的书
Please, don't buy my book on Amazon
导读
一位独立书店老板撰文呼吁读者不要在亚马逊上买他的书，理由是亚马逊的折扣政策让小出版社利润微薄。HN 评论者从出版经济账目入手反驳：零售折扣通常不影响出版社拿到的批发价，如果离开亚马逊就卖不动、留在亚马逊上又赚不到钱，那问题可能出在商业模式而非平台。对写作者来说，这是一堂关于"论证要经得起算账"和"披露利益相关"的公开课。
可以直接用的写作要点
- 01
提出指控前先把账算清楚：如果"在平台上卖利润薄、不在平台上卖又没销量"，读者会判断问题出在商业模式而不是平台。
- 02
区分"读者付多少钱"与"出版社/作者拿多少钱"：零售折扣是渠道行为，批发价通常固定，混淆两者会让论证失去可信度。
- 03
当自己与结论有利益关系时（本文作者恰好开独立书店），主动说明或预先回应，否则读者会自行给你的论证打折扣。
- 04
想让写作者多拿钱，更实际的做法是引导读者从出版社或作者处直接购买，而不是只做道德呼吁。
- 05
对事实性主张（如"亚马逊折扣导致出版社所得很少"）要给出可核查的来源，否则一条评论就能动摇整篇文章。
- 06
用具体数字和对比场景支撑论点，比抽象的"平台压榨"叙事更有说服力。
- 07
面对反驳时预判最强反方观点并正面回应，而不是只向读者"客气地请求"。
- 08
写作中避免"平台拿走利润"这类情绪化概括，改成"平台把折扣让给了消费者"这类可验证的机制描述。
- 09
涉及行业结构性问题时，先把各方利益（出版社、书店、读者、平台）摆清楚，再下判断。
- 10
标题式的行动号召（"别在亚马逊买我的书"）要与正文论证强度匹配，否则容易被读成情绪宣泄。
- 11
引用他人或机构的说法时注明出处，能显著提高说服力。
- 12
承认自己立场的局限（如"我确实开书店"），反而能增强读者对你其余论点的信任。
HN 评论精选
离开平台活不下去，说明问题在商业模式而非平台；亚马逊的折扣实际让利给了消费者。
这个论点站不住脚。小出版社失败，是因为大部分销量来自亚马逊，而在亚马逊上卖利润太薄；不在亚马逊卖，利润会好看些，但销量会断崖式下跌。所以在亚马逊上赚不到钱、不在亚马逊上也赚不到钱，问题恐怕不在亚马逊。亚马逊确实拿走了丰厚利润，但把它让给了消费者。这位作者大概只是客气地请求把利润还回来，好支撑他那套僵化的商业模式；但长远看，人们不太可能为更差的产品付更高的价钱。
JackFr查看英文原文
This argument makes no sense. Small presses fail because they generate the bulk of their sales from Amazon, but the margins are too thin when they sell on Amazon. Presumably if they don't sell on Amazon the margins would be healthier, but sales would drop precipitously. So if you can't make money with Amazon and you can't make money without Amazon it seems to me Amazon isn't the problem. It's true Amazon took the fat margins, but it gave them to consumers. I suppose this guy is just asking nicely to get them back to support his sclerotic business model. But in the long run it's unlikely that people are going to pay more for a worse product. (On the other hand maybe he could sell the book at the locally-grown organic farm stand.)
零售折扣不改变出版社的进货价；作者本人经营独立书店，存在利益冲突。
亚马逊的"折扣政策"和别的书店一样，都是按封面价约45%向出版社进货。一般来说，无论你从亚马逊、从一家满是猫的古怪小书店还是别处买，出版社拿到的钱都一样。直接从出版社买，出版社确实拿到100%的售价；即便他们把其中50%捐给当地书店，仍比你在那家书店买书时赚得多。这一切跟亚马逊无关。我理解亚马逊对小型独立书店（以及大型连锁书店）不利，但我也注意到作者恰好拥有一家小型独立书店，所以对他的其他抱怨要打个大折扣。
joelgrus查看英文原文
"Amazon's discounting policies" are the same as every other bookstore, they pay the publisher ~45% of the cover price for each book. Generally speaking, the publisher gets the same $$ whether you buy the book from Amazon or from Quirky-Bookstore-Full-of-Cats or from wherever. If you buy directly from the publisher, then the publisher does get 100% of the price. And if they donate 50% of that to your local bookstore, they're still making more money than if you'd bought the book from that local bookstore. None of this has anything to do with Amazon. I get that Amazon is bad for small independent bookstores (and for large chain bookstores too!), and I notice that the author just happens to own a small independent bookstore, so take his other complaints with a large grain of salt.
质疑原文的事实前提：平台打折通常不影响出版社每单拿到的固定金额。
我想看到这句话的出处："对许多像 Roundabout 这样的小出版社来说，亚马逊占了销量的很大一部分，但由于亚马逊的折扣政策，出版社从售价中得到的很少。"我的印象是，亚马逊想打多少折就打多少折，但这并不影响出版社每笔销售拿到的固定金额。
oh_sigh查看英文原文
I'd like to see a reference for this statement: "For many small publishers like Roundabout, Amazon accounts for a large portion of sales, but the publisher realizes very little of the purchase price owing to Amazon’s discounting policies." I was under the impression that amazon could discount a book as much as they wanted, but this did not affect the fixed dollar amount that the publisher received per sale.
同类还值得读
写书：值得吗？
Writing a book: is it worth it?
Martin Kleppmann（《设计数据密集型应用》作者）复盘写书到底值不值：金钱回报低、耗时极长，但带来了可见度、信任和职业机会。
出版与作家生涯2020 · 642 分 · 287 评4 条写作要点编辑精选写书并不是个好主意
Writing books is not really a good idea
这篇文章讨论靠写书谋生的现实难度，评论区从版税数学、收入预期和写作目标三个角度补充了作者视角。
出版与作家生涯2021 · 577 分 · 609 评4 条写作要点编辑精选如何自助出版一本书：实用资源清单
How to self-publish a book: A handy list of resources
这是一份关于「如何自助出版一本书」的资源清单帖，涵盖从编辑、排版到 ISBN、销售渠道的实操工具与花费。
出版与作家生涯2018 · 558 分 · 88 评4 条写作要点编辑精选我自助出版一本Ruby on Rails书，赚了7万美元
How I Made $70k Self-Publishing a Book about Ruby on Rails
这是一篇 Ruby 开发者自述：他把一套 Rails 性能课程（书＋视频＋答疑）自出版，一年毛收入约 7 万美元，并总结了选题、定价、营销等经验。
出版与作家生涯2017 · 539 分 · 175 评4 条写作要点编辑精选石黑一雄警告年轻作家因“恐惧”而自我审查
Sir Kazuo Ishiguro warns of young authors self-censoring out of 'fear'
石黑一雄提醒年轻作者因“恐惧”而自我审查，即这条帖子讨论的核心。
出版与作家生涯2021 · 396 分 · 641 评5 条写作要点编辑精选